Superman/Doomsday Omnibus
The story of the continuing conflict between the Man of Steel and his
deadliest enemy in the years after the Death and Return of Superman! This volume
collects SUPERMAN: THE DOOMSDAY WARS 1-3, SUPERMAN/DOOMSDAY:
HUNTER PREY #1-3, DOOMSDAY ANNUAL #1, ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN
#594 and SUPERMAN #175.
User Ratings and Reviews
5 Stars How could this not be good?
I wanted to get the Death of Superman collection since it was first published. This is exactly what I wanted. It is a nice hardcover collection of the comics surrounding the Death of Superman.
3 Stars A Classic is Revisited
With 400-plus pages of prequels and sequels to the classic stories on the death and return of Superman, this collection becomes a mixed bag of oftentimes muddled story lines, but solid artwork.
The stories do not flow together, though there is some outstanding material on the “early” years of Doomsday and an interesting meeting between Doomsday and Darkseid. But there are also some baffling pieces on Doomsday squaring off against the Green Lantern Corps and the pairing up of Superman and Doomsday. The book includes Superman: The Doomsday Wars #1-3, Superman/Doomsday: Hunter Prey, Doomsday Arrival #1, Adventures of Superman #594 and Superman #175.
This is not an essential volume to further appreciate an iconic series, but it has enough tidbits to provide a few solid angles.
5 Stars What a match-up!
Suffice to say, this is a blockbuster of a compliation 
I first got hooked on Superman vs Doomsday with The Death of Superman story (which is also excellent) and was really pleased with the stories in this novel. The art although about 15 years old (for most of the stories) is great with Superman showing his emotions and thoughts in a very real way. He LOOKS real, unlike the modern final story in the compliation where he looks like a blow-up doll due to the different art. This also goes for Doomsday art-wise. He looks scary and menacing in the older style art but looks a bit ridiculous in the 2000 story.
That is the only whinge I have. Buy this now if you can, I highly recommend it.
3 Stars Depressing
Doomsday is just painful to look at and never says anything of interest and no two cartoonists manage to draw him the same way. I’d love to see the DC “bible” on what he’s supposed to look like, because as it stands now, they just throw down any old pile of gray blobs and white-blue cartilage knobs (and those teeth) and they say it’s Doomsday. Well, to distinguish him from a stalagmite they surround him with giant red letters spelling out some mirthful defiant cry of power like HAHAHAHAHA that rings the entire page in horror.
Doomsday’s retreat to Apockolips was the direst and dreariest story I’ve ever read in comics, and I got tired of Darkseid even before he showed up, so what else is there? It didn’t make sense for Doomsday to invade the Green Lantern universe, because, well, it tears the continuity of the book into shreds, if noone in “The Death of Superman” was ever supposed to have seen DD before, and yet he had already been a legend for destroying Green Lantern’s simple existence back during the Renaissance or whenever.
Superman has a great story though trying to save the premature baby of Lana Lang and Pete Ross. The story weaves back and forth between the present and the past, when Clark was about 17 or 18 I guess, and the Kents were about to lose their farm due to the death from freezing of all of their cattle. Now it looks as though Lana, who loved Clark back then and who loves Pete now (or does she?!?!), might lose her infant baby unless Superman can evade Doomsday’s powers of following through the air, for Superman has been charged with bringing baby Ross to a powerful incubator. Eight weeks premature! And so cute. I didn’t find Lana very cute though, not in these pictures, whoever drew her has a grudge against redheads.
5 Stars Gutsy graphic novel
No one can be a lamer character than Superman, but this collection really hits lots of high points. The whole issue of genetic engineering is addressed in a surprisingly intelligent and forceful way. Facing your fears is another powerful theme, and how Doomsday is finally defeated is so clever and so wise it can make you relook at Superman as being a viable character again.
Filed under: Top Superman Comics